| 1933-1935 | Father Thomas Quigley |
| 1942-1946 | Father Francis R. Boyle |
| 1948-1951 | Father Carl P. Milano |
| 1951-1952 | Father Edward J. Boley |
| 1955-1960 | Father Raphael Marzilli |
| 1961-1962 | Father Geno Rivi |
| 1962-1963 | Father Dominic Pozzuoli |
| 1963-1965 | Father John P. McQueeney |
| 1965-1968 | Father Ronald Hatala |
| 1968-1970 | Father Fideles Levri |
| 1970-1974 | Father Hugh J. Meehan |
| 1974-1976 | Father Aloysius J. Bahleda |
| 1976-1977 | Father Emil S. Payer |
| 1977-1979 | Father John M. Foriska |
| 1979-1980 | Father Roger Sinclair |
| 1980-1982 | Father Frank C. Capo |
| 1982-1984 | Father Peter L. Peretti |
| 1984-1985 | Father John T. Euker |
| 1985-1991 | Father Francis H. Rohlf |
| 1991-1995 | Father David W. Rider |
| 1995-1998 | Father Joseph E. Bonafed |
| 1999-2006 (Senior Priest Active) | Father Patrick O'Connor |
| 2015-2017 | Father James B. Morley |
| 2015-2018 | Father James W. Clark |
2017-2018
| Father Patricio Aborde, Jr
|
2018-2019
| Father Anthony J. Klimko
|
| 2018-Present | Father Vincent A. Yee Concepcion |
